Thinking about listing one of them for sale on the bay.. what do you think the condition would be? Thx
It looks VF30 to me, although it might grade a few points higher. Are those marks on the reverse at 9:00 on the coin, or on a mylar surface between the coin and the scanner?
Based on what I can see it is probably XF condition. But it may be a problem coin, I can't tell for sure based on the pics you have.
It may be the scan, but is that maybe damage by the 'E' in E . PLURIBUS on the reverse? The details look like AU to me though.
Matt, I suspect that may be the scan which doesn't show luster well. As for the grade, I have a tough time telling because I grade by luster, but XF or even AU (depending on luster) sounds about right.
No one else mentioned, but I think regardless if it is XF, AU or uncirculated, you will still get the same price for it on ebay - Silver value.