1921 Morgan Dollar GTG with a twist...

Ok, here's a fun exercise. I am posting 4 different 1921 Morgan Dollars for you to guess the grades on. The twist is, there are only two grades to choose from, MS-65 and MS-66. So tell me which Morgans are graded MS-66 and which are graded MS-65. Here's your final clue: There are at least 1 graded MS-65 and at least 1 graded MS-66.

#1


#2


#3


#4

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

1)66
2)66
3)65
4)65

 

I vote the same as above. Using only my left eye, laying on right side.

 

1. 65
2. 66
3. 65
4. 65

 

I have a real love-hate relationship with '21 Morgans. I love collecting them and I hate grading them.

Im going with this:
1=66
2=66
3=66
4=65

But I wouldnt be surprised if 1 was 65 and 4 was 66.

 

If I was grading them without your hints, I would say

MS-65
MS-65
MS-64
MS-64

But since your hints change the game a bit, I will say

MS-65 (only marginally better than the last two, but not as nice as #2)
MS-66 (fewest marks and the best luster of the four by far)
MS-65
MS-65

 

#1 - 65
#2 - 66
#3 - 65
#4 - 65

I really like #4. Focal marks aside it is my favorite of the group and I bet it looks great in hand.

...Cool twist on GTG.

 

1. MS-66
2. MS-66
3. MS-65
4. MS-65

 

66,66,65,65

 

all 65 except number two, which is 66

 

#1 65 ,#2 66,#3 65,#4 65 nice bunch of 21's

 

#2 66

 

66
66
65
65

 

1&2 MS 66
3&4 MS 65

 

2 = 66
rest = 65

 

#1,#3, and #4 MS65, #2, MS66. Nice coins and thoughtful "contest". Thanks JT!

 

1=65, 2=66, 3=66, and 4=65 That's my favorite coin, and that's a very fine collection you have there.

 

Oh, and they're all VAM-3...

 

Agree with the majority here - #2 has the least blemishes on lady liberty's face, which is the prime focal area for most coins - ugly face = ugly coin, regardless of grade