1914 Buffalo error 'S' ?

Anyone seen this error before?

An S under the chin of the Indian
Local dealer asking US$200

Thoughts?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

It is engraved, post mint. Somebody added it, long after the coin was minted.

 

I wouldn't pay $200 for that S. Look at it. It's not even straight, it's sideways.

 

Clashed die, it's from Pluribus on the reverse.

 

It came off Superman's shirt!!

 

http://www.maddieclashes.com/tdc-5c-1914-01/

 

But his is crooked. It's not a clash of the S, I'm sorry. If it's anything it's a counter-stamp and post-mint damage.

 

I think it's thyroid trouble...

 

I agree. Counterstrike. PMD.

 

Same dealer 1863 GB Penny - clipped $US200

I'm no expert but it looks like a hatchet cut

 

NOT your new go-to dealer, I'm afraid.

 

They have a lot more bargains for the unsuspecting. Spot the errors
This is $US200

 

Is this Mercari?

 

Local seller in NZ

 

The date and the denticles jump out as wrong.