1913-S&D Type II Buffalo Nickels or Not?

I took a gamble with a pile of buffalo nickels at a swap meet and I seem to have found these possible gems. I feel confident with one of the coins but need opinions either way, thank you.

Coin #1:

With an obvious S mint mark. To me, I think this one is a solid 1913, but what do you think?

Coin #2:

As you see with this one, it's a bit harder to tell, for me at least because I'm not so much of a buffalo nickel expert.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Coin 2 looks like the loop more aligns with a 5 than a 3. Do an overlay to see if you have a match or not.

 

The second full sized photo Buffalo appears, from this vantage point to be a 1915D. I do not see the proper curvature to indicate a 3. The other looks good.

 

Sorry Kevin, we just crossed over each other and I did not mean to mimic your post.

 

Great minds, Tommy, great minds...Lol

 

They both look like 1915.
Too bad about the condition the 1915-S is a very good coin.

 

That looks like a 1915-S to me.

 

The first one for sure looks like 1913, not sure about teh S