This is why I don't collect Bust Halves. We've had 8 or 10 posted in the last couple of weeks and nobody can agree on a grade or agree with the TPG's. That's not the only reason I don't collect them, but being retired now my financial adviser (wife) has advised me to keep it down.
What do you know??? A TPG grade that I actually agree with (although I also agree with other posters that it would grade higher today). The label is wrong, though. The 4/4 is merely recut--not an overdate.