1652 massachusetts pine tree shilling going cheap

Discussion in 'US Coins Forum' started by hunterscoin, Sep 14, 2010.

  1. hunterscoin

    hunterscoin New Member

  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. zachfromnj

    zachfromnj Junior Member

    How ironic, the coins perfectly round.
     
  4. hunterscoin

    hunterscoin New Member

    yes it was soldered into a silver plate long ago which kept it from getting too damaged as well as a decorative piece
     
  5. brotheratom

    brotheratom Witty coin reference here

    $778.70? For me that ain't cheap.
     
  6. Conder101

    Conder101 Numismatist

    Looks rather thick as well. Of course the lousy pictures don't help.

    I don't have a copy of Noe's book on the Massachusetts silver but I don't recall any with the denomination lettering that broad. None of the pieces listed on the coinfacts page match it, but of course thay don't show all of them.
     
  7. hunterscoin

    hunterscoin New Member


    it's quite thin actually and yeah the pictures arn't amazing! interesting what you said about the denomination lettering though! i took it to the british museum and they said it was a very interesting piece. just wanted to see what you guys thought of it really and if any of you was interested.

    thanks for the reply though!
     
  8. CheetahCats

    CheetahCats Colonial & Early American

    I'm surprised that the museum you took it to didn't attempt to attribute it. Which museum did you take this specimen to?

    Looks to be a [possible] Noe-17 / Crosby-22L / W-840.

    Whitman's Encyclopedia of Colonial and Early American Coins, Bowers, (c) 2009, pg.47, lists this specimen as a URS-9 (125-249 known), and at G-4 = $600US.

    That said, notwithstanding that the specimen is attributable, IMO since the specimen has been seriously altered, IMO at best it is a "net" FR-2. If indeed it is Noe-17, specimens are also somewhat easily attainable in much better and unaltered states.

    Did you solder this specimen to the plate? How did you attain this specimen?
     
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page