What are your thoughts on a grade? I dunno, but it appears whizzed for some reason. Dull appearance between the device & field on the obverse. Do the two spots on the rev kill the value, will they grow? Sorry for so many questions, just can't seem to make up my mind. http://www.ebay.com/itm/1902-Indian...77?pt=Coins_US_Individual&hash=item256bad331d
zack, we have the same opinion. Something is just not right with that coin! It almost looks like a cast fake with porous surfaces. The one thing I AM sure on is that the Experts on this site will chime in and give you a definitive answer. ........or buy it out from under you........
From the pictures the color does look okay to me. One of the spots on the reverse looks like a carbon spot, but the one on the right worries me. If in doubt - then pass it up, I would.