Having had hands on it I would give it AU 58 at best.
I I will give that a go, I believe I have 2 more ICG graded coins ... PR70 GA & CT State Quarters .... )
Lower PR69 instead of PR70, makes a big difference in value.
I have had several ICG graded coins only to have them cross to PR69 by PCGS. It looks like to me that someone rubbed this one with their hand.
By the way I sent one of my own a couple of weeks ago. I paid considerably more and hoping for good results.
It would be worth sending in for PCGS' Restoration service. If it is not restorable then they will just grade it. If it grades higher after...
Separate names with a comma.