Search Results

Search Again
Page 1 of 2
  1. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    Neither am I. But if it is a proof strike on a business strike die wouldn't that be rare aswell?
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  2. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    Is it possible the used the matte proof die on a business strike planchette? Explaining my coin or is it just one of the first coins struck on a...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  3. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    I agree my coin does not have that razor edge but I wanna know why my coin's obverse is detailed like a matte proof and no other coin I have ever...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  4. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    you tell me
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  5. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    I looked at the edge of that coin and that's what mine looks like a 90 degree angle with a slight rounded edge. No bevel like an ordinary business...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  6. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    I just looked at an uncirculated 1934 penny and the edge was considerably rounded much more then the 1917 I have which you can only tell it has...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  7. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    Is it possible that the proof die was struck on a regular planchette? Making the coin have a proof obverse with a slightly rounded edge?
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  8. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    Does anyone have a picture of the edge of an authentic matte proof?
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  9. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    I am second guessing now I looked at the edges of the coin and they look slightly rounded. I am still having it graded but after looking at the...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  10. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    See those pictures of the edge the edges look rounded mine appear to be straight with a 90 degree angle.
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  11. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    We will see on Friday I have the coin I compared it to all the 1917 on here even the PCGS ms64 and my coin has more detail without a doubt. Like I...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  12. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    I just looked at those Lincoln's you posted beautiful coins but still my coin has more detail similar to the matte proofs.
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  13. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    Very unlikely that my 1917 is a matte proof like I said maybe a 1% chance. But I am getting it graded by NGC on Friday in Baltimore. Odds are it's...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 6, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  14. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    Well it would be the rarest Lincoln penny. Funny because I asked a dealer I know who is in his seventies and has been a coin dealer since the...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 5, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  15. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    Explain to me about this obverse die your talking about I have been collecting coins for 24 years but I am by no means an expert on Lincoln...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 5, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  16. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    Who's coin are you referring to?
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 5, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  17. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    My question is if it was a matte proof what would it be worth? 100 dollars, 1000 dollars, or even 10000 dollars? Can anyone give an estimate would...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 5, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  18. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    I compared my 1917 to the picture you posted of your 1917 and my coin has much more detail on the obverse. It looks more like the picture of the...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 5, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  19. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    See my 1917 has a lot more detail in the hair and beard and a deeper temple on Lincoln's head, typical of a matte proof. The coin looks like it...
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 2, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
  20. Mike Carr
    Post

    1917 proof Lincoln??

    so basically if it grades PR DETAILS CLEANED OR PR60 by NGC its a matte proof right they don't put the letter m on the slab right.
    Post by: Mike Carr, Nov 2, 2013 in forum: US Coins Forum
Showing results 1 to 20 of 27 Next >
Search Again
Page 1 of 2