My first impression was AU, my second impression was that the coin just looks hinky. The colors and progressions are strange for a Morgan Dollar....
That coin is spectacular and certainly clean & lustrous enough for a premium gem grade. I don't think it is MS68, because most 68s I've seen have...
+1
I remember this coin, and I hope you get the variety attribution that you are seeking, but I still would have taken the $500. Good luck William!
The reverse looks MS66, but the obvious marks on the obverse focal areas should probably prevent a gem grade, leaving us with an MS64+. It is...
The 54-S is the notoriously worst struck of the entire Jefferson series, but in my experience, often has outstanding luster. It is probably that...
Typically when you see parallel lines on a coin that stop at the design elements, they are usually die scratches/die polish lines, but these...
Given that it is a 1958, I would lean towards NT, those double mint set created some wild color schemes.
And the set is now complete! [IMG] [IMG]
I think this coin is pretty obviously a 43/2-P. The pitfall with this variety is the die spike mimic, but your coin points to the inner curve of...
So do I, especially on Rosies and Franklins, but I prefer toning that looks natural as opposed to the coins in this thread which is best case...
The reason they don't like them is because the toning is artificial. There are plenty of collectors who will say that they don't care whether...
The guy wanted the RPM, I even offered to substitute a gem grade 45-D as a replacement. It boggles my mind as the entire set was problem coins...
There are NGC sets that are better than some of those in the PCGS Registry, but you can't see them because PCGS doesn't allow NGC coins in their...
I'm not interested in making NGC the top service, on the contrary, I just want them to hold their spot. For lack of a better analogy, I don't...
This whole thread scares me. If I can get the auction winner to accept a replacement coin, I will pull it and send it your way.
So you agree with me. They can’t ban PCGS coins from their registry and they can’t do nothing and allow PCGS to take their lunch money everyday....
But being PCGS’ b*tch is good for their brand?
They stopped doing that, in order to be eligible any monetary award, your set must be comprised of at least 75% NGC graded coins. My contention...
This has nothing to do with their customer service attitude, its about protecting their company. As long as the registry system is structured as...
Separate names with a comma.
