I agree! That's great value for a beautiful coin!
Points table: Beefer518 - 31.26 Points ddddd - 30.26 Points baseball21 - 26.61 Points heavycam.monstervam - 22.51 Points ddoomm1 - 18.51 Points...
Anything is possible I guess :p
By the way, luster is a factor: “NGC assigns its trademarked Star Designation to coins with exceptional eye appeal for their assigned grade. Eye...
While I agree with all of that (and posted my own thread on it...linked below), I have seen NGC be quite casual with the star in the past few...
I’ll have a post later tonight, but anyone can jump in if you have something ready.
The have a verification tool on their homepage: http://www.icgcoin.com/ And a population search: http://www.icgcoin.com/population-search/
@BlueCole this must have been quite the find! Hopefully you won’t wait 16 years for your next post! :D By the way, does that set the record for...
I'm sure if I used the NGC photo we would see people guessing AU Details-Polished :p
The obverse (and semi-PL is what I said)
See above :) (PL qualities) And I bought it as-is (I didn't send it in). One can argue that it might only be a 63, but it's not lower than that...
Yes the light source is different and it's semi-PL. If you tilt the coin, you can see some die polish lines on the obverse.
Since you asked nicely :) ...it's MS 64 STAR [ATTACH]
And I wouldn’t question it in a 65 holder. It looks at least like a high end 64 in my opinion.
No hints; I’m just saying the other coin posted isn’t a 62. It was in a 63 holder before and definitely should not have down graded-unless the...
62 is low on that coin; it might even be a mechanical error. I certainly wouldn’t judge other Walkers based on that result.
The answer might give away the result. ;) I’ll comment on this after the reveal.
I usually give these 24-48 hours so that more people would have a chance to see it. @physics-fan3.14 @C-B-D ...others feel free to guess too :)
Seems like you might make the seller happy...maybe this whole thread was started to get someone to buy that coin and prove the OP wrong? The...
Please guess the grade. :) [ATTACH]
Separate names with a comma.
