Which Rainbow you prefer?

Same date, mintmark, and photographer. Id like to know which one you prefer. thanks

Coin 1 Obverse

Coin 1 Reverse

Coin 2 Obverse

Coin 2 Reverse


thanks:thumb:

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I prefer the impossible of course: Coin 1 obverse with Coin 2 reverse

 

im going to agree with Krispy on that one butwould have to go with the second

 

I like #2 the way it is

 

very interesting! I will elaborate at why i asked the question later on, because theres definitely a reason behind the question.

 

I'm intrigued! Can't wait to hear what you have to add.

 

I would take #2. It is probably the pictures, but #1 does nit look like it has any luster left.

 

I like coin #2. The reverse toning is much more impressive and I actually really like the variegated toning on the obverse. I think it gives the coin character. Besides, there are toning breaks on the obverse of coin #1 as well.

 

The reverse of coin #2 is amazing, but if I was spending my money I would go with coin #1.

 

I guess #1 but it's only ok to me.
I do like #2's reverse but the obv is too much for me.

 

#1 is better
#2 observe is nasty. It makes me wanna puke !!

 

I'd take number 1! The second one is nice but in comparison I gotta go with #1!

 

I'd take #1. It has just the right amount of toning. The obverse of #2 has a little too much for me.

 

I prefer the one with the "pot of gold" beneath it!
(and the 1869s... as well)

But #2 reverse does it for me..nice color!

RB

 

I like #1 better. The splotchy look on Roosevelt's face on #2 makes it look like he has another disease, and it draws your attention away from anything else.

So, on which one are you going to bid?

Chris

 

I prefer the golden tones of #2 not sure if it is the lighting on #1 but the coin itself loos sort of matt no shine to it at all

 

Put them both in an NGC multi-coin holder with the obverse of #1 and the reverse of #2 facing forward.

I like #1.

 

You would not care to explain a little, would you Doug?