Well pony up some grades in the other thread if ya'll want to play... Round 1 is gonna get scored this weekend.
You boys better bring your A game. :kewl: Oh yeah, please leave out the 3rd world slabs -- using them makes a good guess more important than grading ability, IMO.
No kidding,, I can tell this thing is gonna be a tight race already. What tpgs do we want to exclude... ? I really don't consider PCI and SEGS to be 3rd world,, more like 2nd world... My recommendation would be to include ANACS, NGC, PCGS,,, and then PCI and SEGS with appropriate guidance to the group in advance if the grade appears to be off in either direction..... also, just a note, most of the PCI and SEGS coins I have I consider to correctly graded or undergraded. Anyway,, Ya'll let me know, I'll let the majority rule here.
I am sorry, but what I did to grade your other slabs (ANACS included) was to determine the grade and then add something. That is not grading, but guessing. The only exceptions to that might be the old small ANACS slabs or the old ICG slabs. Sorry, but I cannot be more specific for ICG.
Fair enough,,, thankfully, almost all my anacs slabbed coins are in the old small holders. I'll keep it to the big 3.... starting in round 2.