set of ICG MS-69 Silver Eagle

I'm New to coins and I just randomly chose 1 oz silver eagle's to collect.

I heard that ICG was on ok grader.

So I started just getting random MS69 coins off E-bay.

But Now I'm moving and I want to sell my collection and I'm not sure what it's worth. Or even if I should be selling now? I tried to look on ebay for a SET from 1986 to 20XX years from ICG but no one seems to be selling those.

So what I have... Your help is greatly appreciated!

ICG MS69's from 1986-2002 that's 17 coins ... And I have 2003 - 2005 MS70's ICG with 2004 being a first day of issue whatever that means.

So... My question is do I sell the entire lot that way? Or do I just sell the 69's in one lot and 70's in another?

Is ebay the way to sell these or is there a better way? :hammer:

Thanks a lot... and how much do you think I should get for this?

----

Eric

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I've heard pros and cons about ICG.

Are your ASEs bearing a mm or no?

I've seen a complete set of ASEs from 1986 - 2008 listing for around $1500 for proofs.

 

Try photobucket.com when your ready to post

 

It means the coin has been certified as one issued on the first day the 2004 ASEs were available.

If you run a search on eBay for first strike or first day American Silver Eagles, there are some in PCGS slabs labeled that way too.

 

I would try eBay. If it were me I would sell them each individually but I don't know too much about these coins so I would listen to other's opinions first.

 

I agree,each individually will bring better money,than one whole lot.unless your selling price is really good.If your just looking to "dump" them and make a couple bucks,then you may want to find a dealer that will buy them all.maybe even someone here would.

 

Picked up an ICG MS-70 ASE on auction before. Looking at the coin, have my doubts it's really MS-70. Maybe 68 or 69. It's not given me much much reason to have faith in ICG.

 

I try not to talk about people,or companies,I let them speak for themselves.The only ICG I would buy is very interesting pieces.At that point of looking at it,I would grade the coin myself.

 

The old adage, buy the coin, not the case.

 

A dealer would probably offer around $1100 for the whole set. My dealer pays what he can buy them for wholesale. Their is one dealer advertising in Coin World Magazine saying he pays $2 back of bid pricing. You would need a current copy of the Coin Dealer Newsletter to get each coin's bid price less the $2.

I just realized these are MS coins. My estimate was for PR coins