The Toning Premium Thread

What did I sell this MS 62 1890-O Toned Morgan for at the same show as the Eagle from my earlier post?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

That's a nice reverse strike for that Mint. Too bad the obverse is so chewed up. I'll start the bidding at $495 on the theory somebody has to be nuts about that color.

 

Greysheet is $125, the color is nice but not crazy good, I say 2X, $250.

 

This coin was purchased for $700 when Mark Feld was a dealer. It was in a NGC 66 holder and subsequently received the CAC green. Was sent raw to NGC 6 months ago and graded 67. CAC did not rebean. What did it sell for in March 2022?

 

The 1890-O sold for $350; @Lehigh96 was closer than @eddiespin

For the Peace Dollar from @Catbert , I would guess the grade carried the value (67 is where those get expensive). I will guess $2,500

 

I don't think the toning had much to do with the final price of that Peace Dollar but I will say $3K

 

Amazing luster/strike and color.
$3600.

 

And the answer is:

https://www.greatcollections.com/Coin/1135525/1925-Peace-Silver-Dollar-NGC-MS-67-Toned

 

Oh, I nailed that!


I submitted this 1944-D Jefferson Nickel to NGC and it came back MS67 and I sold it recently, how much did it sell for? Greysheet is $60

 

$185

 

@Lehigh96 Well, you almost nailed it. Ya know the buyer's fee counts in the cost!

 

$210

 

$250.00

 

Anyone else before the reveal?

 

$129

 

Winner, it sold for $125!

 

Pretty coin. Really nice toning.

 

$25 coin, $100 NGC MS67 plastic. Ah, inflation.

 

Isn’t that how the original format was? I like it better that way.
I’d prefer just to guess the BUY price.