Would the rim damage on the obverse make this a details coin? Or would this come out as a clean Fine.
For 685 that's outta my spend mark. Trying to find a good 85 cc. Was hoping for a cheaper raw, but it looks like slabbed is about the same price. Best I found is 885 for an PCGS MS63.
Unfortunately 1885 CC are rare in any grade. IMO the first coin shown is a VG Details. If I were buying the graded MS63 is the better choice but your choice may different as you know your collection. It is extremely unlikely prices will go down much.