i havent submitted any of my own coins for grading but i definately prefer the looks of a NGC holder to PCGS.
As you see your not going to get anyone to agree here. That's why there are more then one TPG'er I will get any slab but I have experience looking at coins so I feel that I'm good enough. If you collect long enough you will to. When it comes to a 16d dime though I still want at least one of the top 4 to have graded it just in case. All this planning on this...I'd just see what ones you like and go for it. Being cents maybe I'd look for just PCGS but I personally would not pass on a good NCG at a great price. And I doubt you will either no matter what you decide. Good luck and keep us informed.
I see what you are saying. Even if I get a coin that is graded by another company, later on if I really want I can always send it to PCGS and have them grade it to to mach the set. Once again guys, I appreciate all the input.