Here we go. First - forget the RD, RB, BN designation... too much work, will stick with simple points off grade and a 10pt shot any missed on BB's. Good participation on the last thread.. Second - if anyone is uneasy or would not like thier names ranked let me know and I'll remove from the weekly recap and rankings. Third - you have to have 4 guesses submitted before ranked. We now have 10 ranked members... 12 pending more submissions. On to the rankings: comment - even with crappier pictures than the first batch, most members actually did much better with these two and the tendency for most was a trend down in averaged points off of actual pcgs grade (da score).... Duke K. once again led the group, with a net 1 point cumulative off of actual.. or .5pts off average.... very strong. HA award went to Jon67, sorry Shoe :smile. Rankings: PCGS grading rankings. DUKE KAVANAGH 2.00 BADTHAD 2.75 RLM'S CENT 3.75 SHAWN151 4.75 MARK_H 5.50 BULLY 6.25 ABE 6.75 MIKENOODLE 6.80 BORGOVAN 8.75 GDJMSP 9.17 PCGS less that 4 rankings. LDHAIR 0.00 MPCUSA 0.33 COINKEEPER 1.00 CANERCOINS 1.00 LOUIE_TWO_BITS 1.00 BGCOINS 5.00 COPPERMANIA 5.50 PJH008 6.00 COPPERWIRED 7.67 SHOEWRECKY 10.00 SWEET WHEATZ 17.50 JON67 25.00 DGS less than 4 rankings. BULLY 1 DUKE KAVANAUGH 1 MIKE NOODLE 1 LATHER 1 MARSHALL 10 RZAGE 16 Round two ! I spent time today taking the best pics I could of the next two, so there will not be any updated pics of these at the end of this thread..... Next 2 are PCGS also. 1925-d 1922-d
Man I was really trying to get that HA award. Maybe I will have better luck this time. 25-D MS63 22-D MS62 _Shrek
I am going to say both are 63's by a tpg. I would probably grade them both 62's for the weak strikes and tick marks.
It's always interesting to see how the wear above the ear on lincoln's in is interpreted by pcgs graders.... on the day these were graded, the wear above the 25d's was taken more as "wear" than it was strike...... 25D - AU58 22D - MS62 Almost everyone missed the 25D... Lots of folks around the 22D... I was looking forward to Dukes picks on these.. too bad he didn't chime in. Will post 4 new one's in the next thread, along with updated standings.
58 on the 25d just a bit to much rub on the wheat although weak strike is common 63 on the 22d several hits but I like it Someone has a nice collection of Lincolns for sure
Well at first I thought wow everyone picked higher then me and I was gonna be way off then boom I see that I missed the thread all together!! Then I thought what was this thread up 5 hours but no I missed it some how I would have been real close it seems though. I still want that 22d
