Looks like you found a roll that a collector already went through and kept the very best, tossing these into a roll to be sent back to the bank. Those they kept must of been beauties. LOL
Two different finishes.... one regular the othe satin. One came in rolls the other in a mint set....you been eduamacated....
So you have ms nickels as well nickels at times minted with a different finish. The tube of satins all came from us mint sets. The string&son,inc. Were 1st day released in D.C.