these are 2 nickels i just won. they are raw coins. i already have the 1944 D in MS66 but i needed the 1944 P for my collection. question is what do you guys think these pair grade at. these pictures are from the auction as i do not have the coins in hand as of yet. i will try to post my own pictures once i get the coins. thanks in advance :thumb: 1944 P 1944 D
I would grade the P MS-63 and I would grade the D MS-65. The D might have Full Steps, but it's hard to tell from that pic.
1944-P: MS64 1944-D: MS65 The white balance looks off in the photos and I would expect them to appear less toned in hand. The 1944-P has some significant marks that should prohibit a gem grade but the luster looks very good. The 1944-D has a better strike and good luster and no major marks but a number of small abrasions. I have no problem giving it a gem grade. It might go MS66 but I would need to see better photos to give it that grade.
MS-63, 64, for the "P" 64, 65 for the "D" MS-63, 64, for the "P" 64, 65 for the "D". The "P" is rather tough in higher grades compared to the other war nicks.
I like 'em. Keep in mind that war nickels are known for strong strikes, especially the D-Mints. Your '44-D is no exception, and I think there's a good chance that it would merit a Full Steps designation. Of course, they don't pay me to grade...
thanks for all the input. :thumb: the grades i am seeing are kind of the ballpark i was thinking. still working on getting my coin grading skills down. paper currency is my main thing.
