PCGS sub has arrived - Guess the Grade (Part 1 of 5)

Both times PCGS (unless you were predicting the NGC grade and I misunderstood ).

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

My guesser is broken right now, so I'll wait for the reveal.

 

Reveal later tonight and then part 2 of 5 will follow.

 

Looking forward to it!! I need some practice in these GTG's...

 

This one graded the same both times: MS 64.
Below is an image of the original holder (don't have a picture in the new holder yet).
I was a bit disappointed here as the coin looked nicer than a 64. It's also semi-pl. Taking the nice color into the equation, I thought PCGS would market grade this as a 65 but I guess it wasn't meant to be.

 

Darn was right the first timeI'm really surprised how it didn't upgrade to at least gem still its a beauty.

 

Wow, their masks must be fogging up their glasses. I'd give it a 65 for sure. The color bump alone should have been enough to get it there.

 

I agree. Of the five coins I sent in, this was the one I was most confident in!
So much for that confidence.

 

Part 2 has been posted here:
https://www.cointalk.com/threads/pcgs-sub-has-arrived-guess-the-grade-part-2-of-5.385010/

 

MS64+

 

I'm thinking higher than most. Original MS65, now MS66

 

Which is the real coin. I’m guessing #2. Both 64

 

Hey. I got one right this year. And it’s only august

 

No thanks. Don’t want to make an ass out of myself. Happy being 1 for 1.

 

That's fair! You got this one right and might as well call it a day (I know I've done that before ).

 

I think they screwed the pooch on this one. That coin is clearly a gem in terms of surface preservation. I don’t know what they were thinking, holding it at 64, especially given the eye appeal of the toning. Totally SMH on this one! 65 to 65+ should have been a no-brainer!

 

I had guessed 64 to 65! Looks nice.

 

That's what I thought too. No luck on this particular coins (I'd argue they were actually quite conservative given the color).

 

Here is a video of the coin I just posted:
https://www.instagram.com/p/CSsYlRKLb1z/

 

Leave the pooch out of it!