Battle of guess the grade 1881-CC’s

All below are two different 1881-CC’s. I want you to guess the grade for each and which one is the overall higher grade.
I will post glam shots first and then side by side in the same lighting tomorrow in the PM. Also to note one of these coins got the CAC sticker. Can you guess which one.

Coin # 1


Coin # 2

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

1 62DPL/DMPL 2 66CAC

 

Top one got the CAC sticker, I'm going with PF64 on that one.
I'm tempted to go with PL on the second one but I'm going to stay on the safe side and go with MS66

 

1881 CC's don't exist in proof only the 1881P's are.

 

Well dang, sure looks like a proof! lol, learn something new everyday...

 

1. 64+PL
2. 66+ ( and maybe better, kinda out of my league.)

 

#1. 64 PL
#2 66

 

64 + CAC first one 65 second

 

hey @Kozmo70 great looking coins. I'm going with MS63+ on the 1st Morgan and MS64 on the 2nd Morgan. good luck to ya

 

This is making me think I need to have one of them regraded lol.

 

Side by side shows a little more.

coin #1, originally thought 64PL. drop it to 63PL due to visible chatter. Maybe 62PL.

coin #2, originally thought 66. Drop it to 65, maybe 64.... just depending on those 2 unfortunate hits

They are both incredibly beautiful.

 

#1 63 PL
#2 64+
I will say

 

Both are MS66.
The first got a + for semi PL.
The second got the CAC.

 

1-63PL 2 same.

 

#1. 62 DMPL
#2. 65. CAC

 

1. 63PL 2. 65CAC

 

Based on the second set of photos of the obverse, I must lower my grade estimates. The original pictures made the coins look far higher in grade than the second set. I would call coin #1 now a 64, and coin #2 a 63. It is all in the photographs. Which set is accurate?

 

Original photos:
65...semi-pl but not quite enough for PL
66...cleaner than the first

Updated photos:
63...cheek looks a lot more baggy
64+...some of the hits/marks look more severe than I thought

 

I think they are both MS64PL.

 

63 and 65 CAC