What would you grade this Buff?

I got this Buff and it's in an OLD PCGS slab...I think its a good for it grade but might get up'ed one point if sent back in...its not worth the re-grading fee or I would but what do you think it grades...
After a few people guess I'll tell what PCGS has on it...
It has great luster--not a lot of digs or marks...and the ones that are there you don't see too good...

Speedy

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Ms-64?

 

Nice looking coin! I'd give it an MS-62.

 

A little weak in some areas, but still a fairly solid 64.

 

My guess AU-58 because of weakness on buffalo tail, front leg shoulder area, horn, ear tip, and hair above indians hair ribbon. In my experiences with PCGS they have always graded hard.

 

Ranchhand--OldDan--GDJMSP
You guys agree with me...I saw M--PCGS graded it MS--its in a rattle slab...it was my first UNC Buff and at the time I wasn't look for one but was out of town for a few days and at a fleamarket some guy had it...didn't want much and I thought it was good for the grade maybe a plus...so I got it...I'm glad I did.

Thanks again ya'll

Speedy

 

I would also guess it's a 4, that rim ding on the rev is really holding it back. Nice coin!! I'm jealous.

 

Hey Cave Troll

I pulled out the coin and looked and there isn't a rim nick like it looks in the photo...the nick is part of the PCGS old holders--at least that is what it looks like...

Thanks for the 4--I'm glad I was right on this one

Speedy

 

what was the original grade on the holder?

 

Yep--MS63...I had typed the post before I posted it and put "--"in where I should have put 63 and 64....

Speedy

 

You should send it off to SGS, they will give you a ms-70 grade for that............

 

Btw, that was meant in jest.

 

I hope so !!!

Speedy

 

'course with all the gradeflation going on these days, you may see MS65. Nice coin regardless

 

Might but if I ever do send it in it will go to ANACS and I think I heard they were hard on Buffs..

Speedy

 

yea you can tell the nick is in the holder after bein told. nice coin get that 4

 

Whooo!!! I have that exact same coin a 1935 with the same die wear and the same grade, in a pcgs rattler holder

 

Mine is also in a rattle slab...

Speedy