For GSA's...PCGS or NGC????

Hi all,
I have recently picked up a couple of nice GSA CC dollars, a nicely toned '84 and a real nice DMPL '83. I am debating the merits of sending them to a TPG. I see the NGC ones and they keep the coin in the original holder and put a grading tape around the holder. PCGS however, wants the coin submitted in the original holder, which they then break out, put in their holder and pedigree it as a GSA. I am seeking advice as to which might be the best avenue to go down. I like the idea of NGC keeping the coin in its original holder......history and all. PCGS certified stuff seems to bring a better $ amount when time to sell. Any thoughts?
Thank you in advance,
George

I am inserting a couple of pics of the obv of the coins...the DMPL has just a touch of toning on the obv, and the reverses of both coins are white.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Here's a better shot of the '83 showing the light toning.
George

 

Nice Morgans! I really don't think there's that much of a difference between PCGS and NGC when it comes GSA Morgans, mainly because while some people would pay a premium for PCGS coins, there are also people who will pay a premium for coins in the GSA cases. I would say go with what ever company you like better. Personally I would probably send them to NGC, just because I like the GSA holders.

 

If you plan on selling I would go with PCGS, otherwise pick the one you like best. Just my humble opinion.

 

Congrats on the CCs !

I prefer NGC for this, since they keep 'em in the original GSA holders. But there's a bigger factor...

Check pricing on certified GSAs. Find the grade point at which "slabbed" GSAs sell for more than non-slabbed (probably MS64ish). Only submit yours if you feel they will grade that high.

Yours look pretty strong.

 

I agree that yours look unusually nice, and remarkably free from bag marks. I also think that others have been right on with what they've said. Chances are the the GSA holder more or less compensates for any "PCGS premium."

 

Thanks for the imput everyone. I leaned toward NGC for the reason of keeping the coins in the original GSA holders. This all helps in my decision making process.
George