the arc is a dirt line where it appears that another coins was on top of it. The coin has great detail but is fairly dirty. I don't clean coins ever.
A dirt line ? It appears to be raised metal But you have the coin in hand - all we have are pics. But like I said in the beginning - the only way to know for sure is to have the coin authenticated. Now wait a minute - if it's a dirt line why does it pass under the stars and Liberty's head instead of on top of them ?
Oddly enough - the one you provided Jody. Click here Scroll down to the bottom of the page. They are off on the mintage - they may be off on this as well.
You must be confused, Doug (Or maybe it's me. LOL). That sentance (on that webpage) is talking about 1876-CC 20 cent pieces, not Trade Dollars. There were only 10,000 minted.
Is there any chance of getting a clearer picture of the lower right quadrant of the reverse? From what I can see, the relationship of the wingtip, the laurel leaves, and the words "900 FINE" don't appear to be quite right. I also have some question about the placement of the ribbon below "STATES OF" at the top.
Just to bring things up to speed. I had this coin examined by 4 dealers at a local Coin show. All of them agree, it is a fake. I actually returned to the dealer I bought it from and told him I wanted to sell the coin. He asked where did i get it. I said "from you" he said "why do you want to sell it?" I told him "I just wasn't into the coin any longer." he then looked thru his case and thru a 1939 walking Half at me and said "here you'll like this." I asked " straight trade" he said "give me $20 and were even". He said the coin shoud grade at a MS65. SO now I have a walker for $90. I will try and post a picture it is really nice. I was very suprised at the outcome. I expected him to react poorly.
Heh, the fact that you paid $90 for a high-end, scarce trade dollar is probably the biggest tip-off of all
I actually paid $70 and he said it was a low grade, It was an impulse buy, and I knew nothing about trade dollars at the time.
Well if the Walker actually grades at least MS64 you did OK But always remember this - if somebody sells you a fake coin, take it back and ask for a full refund. They cannot refuse. And I would be careful about buying coins from that person in the future. Now there are many dealers that have been fooled by fakes and perhaps this guy was - he may have thought the coin genuine. But even it that was true - do you want to buy coins from someone that can't identify a fake ??