Unusual N. Song 1 cash coin

I have just received a Yuan Feng Tong Bao 1 cash coin from a usually reliable source.

The closest match I can find is Hartill 16.233, but the Bao looks a bit different, and the top stroke of the Yuan is definitely unusual.

Diameter is 23.8mm and weight 2.8g.

Is this Northern Song or perhaps a Vietnamese copy?

What do you experts think?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I don't know anything about Japanese coins but my guess is that it is a "small character" version Nagasaki coin similar to the one illustrated at this website:
http://www.history.ucsb.edu/faculty/roberts/coins/Nagasakiexport.html

Gary

 

You could very well be right. Very interesting. as I only paid A$1.60 for this and another coin, I don't feel cheated!

Thanks for the info.

Richard

 

Authentication as a Japanese coin requires a look at the reverse.

 

Here's the reverse. What are we looking for?

 

This is another where the Bao doesn't look right. Is this a Nagasaki coin, do you think?

 

Either the absence of any characters or a single character at the top denoting that it was cast in Tokyo.

Chinese, Korean and Annamese coins virtually all have more than one character on the reverse.

 

I don't think its a coin at all. Most probably a temple token or "charm".

 

The vast majority of Northern Song coins and many of those from other Chinese dynasties have reverses with NO characters.

 

I have been informed by Luke Roberts that the coin is a Nagasaki Export coin of the "fat character" type. It is a common variety worth a couple of dollars.

Here is a link to Luke's excellent page:
http://www.history.ucsb.edu/faculty/roberts/coins/Nagasakiexport.html

 

Excellent resource. Bookmarked. Thankyou very much!:high5: