This is a coin I picked out of a put together roll of 58 D's a couple of years ago. It resides in an old ANACS 65 Red holder. This is the coppecoins link http://www.coppercoins.com/lincoln/diestate.php?date=1958&die_id=1958d1mm021&die_state=mds and here is my coin
Yup, that's the one. It's the only suspected 5-mintmark die in the Lincoln cent series. Reason I say 'suspected' is because some agree, others do not, and there's no way to actually prove it one way or the other. My eye sees a D/D/D&D&D cent....really messed up die!
