Therein lies one of my favorite discussions (and my opinion)....COINS SHOULD ONLY BE GRADED ON ACTUAL PHYSICAL WEAR and NOT die state.
That is why I said to disregard the color. The color in hand is nothing like that. I am experienced enough to know a cleaned coin when I see one, and this is definitely not one of them.
Why don't you try and get some more pictures. Maybe it will be easier for us all to agree on something.
Coop Yep, thats the show. I have my spot reserved for the next year, I am always by the snack bar ( most traffic he he he ) See you soon I hope
The Booth on the right of it? I've bought stuff from the guy there before about 5 years back. Jay lets me know when he gets some rolls of BU Cents. That's my specialty.