Guess the Grade 1893S Morgan

Hey guys I have this 1898 S Morgan Silver dollar, It's been graded by NTC or the Numistrust Corporation ( I know I know ). What grade would you give the coin, and then I will tell what NTC gave it.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

93?

 

that's a 1898 S

 

1898-s, and au-58 cleaned.

 

That was dumb sorry 1898 S. I was thinking about another coin while I was typing.

As for cleaned the pictures aren't the best sorry, but I can still see the cartwheel on the coin.

 

I think about them sometimes too.

 

Wow just checked the prices on the 1893 S, I wouldn't mind having that one instead. I bet this thread is going to get a ton a views lol.

 

Your picking remind me of one washed with baking soda or something like that. I will say AU55 - and the NTC grade is like MS65.

 

Lol no worries on the date.

 

AU55. I don't know about cleaning. I'm thinking probably cleaned, but hard to tell from the pics.

 

AU Cleaned & re-toned. Net EF.
Very best regards,
collect89

 

i am just guessing here, but i will say AU 50, but they graded it an MD 61

 

I would say a AU58
Jazzcoins Joe

 

they called it an 1893?
LOL.
J/K

Au, them= MS-61

[Mood= Grumpy]

 

Yea sorry for the pics haven't mastered the Macro pics yet. Anyway the generous graders at Numistrust gave it a MS62

 

Well I guess the whole gang are doing a lot of drinking at the third party grading company .NTC

I would never send my coins there. I could not see how a coin with wear can even make an MS grade it;s not an uncirculated coin

Well they were drunk for sure or blind one of the two. I put red were the extensive wear is I can't believe it MS 62 over graded indeed.

Jazzcoins Joe

 

98 s's are not known for strong strikes in fact the opposite. I think it's a nice looking coin (especially in the last photo). I vote ms.

 

Assuming it was never cleaned and is a weak strike, that's not a 62 coin by any stretch IMO.

 

i think those morgan dollars are the most beautiful coins the u.s. mint ever produced. i loved looking at those pictures in this thread.