It's a nice looking coin, one I wish I owned. I do not profess to know anything about Buffalo nickels numismatically, though, so I would not hazard a guess. There is apparent wear on it, though, that is plain to see.
I know practically nuttin' about this series but that doesn't stop me from play-grading. Taking into consideration a full horn & tail, possibly a weak strike. Also figuring in ANAC's grading...... 58-61! (How far off was I?) J.T. Mr. Geezer, That being said, I rather doubt there are many members of CT that would kick this 'Bison' outa their collection...Ha!