Guess the Grade, 1937 Boone

Recently purchased this Boone commem in a Rattler holder. It has full swirling luster and even toning that appears to be medium gray with a golden-pink overtone (peach?) The images don't show the color well, but pick up some color in the recesses. What do you think it graded?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

In a rattler ms 63

 

MS 65

 

58

 

'64 in the 'rattler', '65 in present day.........

 

If the luster is as nice as you say (difficult to confirm from the picture), I'd say it graded MS-65.

 

yes the luster is complete, no breaks or weak areas.
I'll post the grade tomorrow night.

 

ms-64

 

66 if this is on the holder:


65 if it's on the coin

 

I’m in the MS65 camp

 

I've looked from multiple angles with a loupe, and I just can't see that. so I think it's a shadow from the slab which has some abrasions. sharp eye!

 

65

 

Nice. Very original and crusty look with good eye appeal. 65.

 

MS 65 in Rattler, destined for a 66 in a present day PCGS or NGC slab.
Edit: changed ‘modern‘ to ‘present day’.

 

Commemorative are difficult for me to grade as they mostly tend to grade MS65 unless there is proof of cleaning or damage, so that's my guess.

 

MS-64

 

The holder probably says 64.

 

MS-65 more or less this way I can be right.

 

MS-66+

 

66