Opinions on these please.....

Discussion in 'US Coins Forum' started by GrimReaper, Apr 9, 2005.

  1. GrimReaper

    GrimReaper Senior Member

    what would you guys grade these ?? thanks in advance ;) , hope they are good enough !
     

    Attached Files:

  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. Pennycase

    Pennycase New Member

    For the top pictures in order, Fine, VF , G , XF, for the morgans, i'd say AU's ??? Hard to really tell from the pics

    I take that back, VF for the barber.
     
  4. GrimReaper

    GrimReaper Senior Member

    you can actually see the BERT in the LIBERTY itself on the V nickel , when it's in hand , all letters visible in the LIBERTY on the penny & dime also.
     
  5. GrimReaper

    GrimReaper Senior Member

    i would also say the dime looks better & the penny looks way better when they are in hand!
     
  6. crystalk64

    crystalk64 Knight of the Coin Table

    I don't believe any of the Morgans will make AU! To much wear on both the obverse and reverse. The Morgan in the center is the best of the 3 but without seeing them up close and personal I wouldn't want to try and give an actual grade but will say they two of them should make VF. Thats the best I can do from these photos.
     
  7. cdcda

    cdcda New Member

    Barber Dime: VF
    Indian Head Cent: VF
    Liberty Head Nickel: Hard to say from the photo but looks like G or VG
    1883-S Morgan: XF
    1878 Morgan: XF
    1880-S and 2nd 1878: AU or better, need better pictures
     
  8. pob374

    pob374 New Member

    By using Photograde I would grade them as follows:
    Barber Dime = Fine
    Indian Head= Fine
    Liberty Head Nickel=Good
    1883 Morgan=Ex.Fine
    1878 Morgan=Ex.Fine
    1880 Morgan=Ex.Fine
    1878 Morgan=Ex.Fine
    Good Luck, Hope this helps. Norm
     
  9. MorganFred

    MorganFred New Member

    Guess I'm not adding much here since the others seem to have already pitched in and as stated earlier, it's very difficult to grade coins from scans, but the Morgans all appear to be no more than XF with the possible exception of the '78 which might make low AU. However,without the coins in hand or larger/better pics, I wouldn't bet the farm on these grades. One thing I've learned over the years with Morgans is that whatever it looks like from scans, the chances are the actual grade will be lower.
     
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page