My guess is 58. It looks like there is some luster disturbance on her left hip next to WE. It also looks like some wear on the eagle wings. Only other thing I see is what appears to be some dirt in the letters and devices which to me hints that it spent some time circulating.
Lovely SLQ. MS63. I agree with folks it doesn't appear to be FH based on the photos. Looks like the holder is scuffed right where you'd expect to see headband feathers for FH.
63, Not FH. I was trying to determine whether I see a tiny bit of wear on the high points, but I finally decided this was not rub. If I saw the coin in hand, I might have to change my mind
This is exactly where I am. My official vote is also 63, not FH. But I could easily see that it might be 58.
Yes, it could an AU-58 too. The duller spots could wear or envelope toning. That’s why grading from photos is imprecise.
To me, it's obvious this coin has slight wear in several areas, head and shield on the obverse and along the eagle's wing and breast on the reverse. AU-58.