To CAC or not to CAC - official game thread

The light makes both a bit difficult to read, but from what I can see both look solid to me.
Texas-Green
Oregon-Green

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

That Texas half is drop dead gorgeous. I think both are solidly graded and could go green.

 

I'm ready to go when I get to the front of the line.

 

I say green on both Texas and Oregon. Definitely solid for the grade if not PQ.

 

Yeah, I'll go green on both of them.

 

Let's let this run until tomorrow and then @Publius2 can go

 

OK, I guess I'm up. Here's a 1893 Isabella Commemorative Quarter, NGC MS-64. What do you think? Bean or no-bean?

 

I like it but for some reason my first impression was NO Sticker
(maybe the photo is playing tricks with my eyes )

Edit: will update summary info after this round

 

Solid. Greenie.

 

OR - Green CAC
TX - Green CAC
Isabella- No sticker

 

No bean on the Isabella. A fair bit of chatter and hints at a dip.
I'm probably a harsh grader tonight, tough day.

 

Maybe it's the photo but the coin looks dipped with luster left. I don't know here...tough one. Maybe it's just I expect some toning on this issue. I guess it was a Bean. ???

jom

 

Maybe it is the photo but I agree with No Bean for the reasons given above.

 

Oregon green
Texas no bean (looks dipped)
Isabella no (dipped)

 

Green to both TX and OR but no to Isabella

 

The Texas and the Oregon are really pretty. Yes to both. The Isabella looks off. No to the Isabella.

 

No sticker on Isabella looks dull

 

I'll also say yes to green beans on TX and OR, but no on Isabella.

 

The reveal about 5 pm ET.

 

You need to start out with a drum roll.