To CAC or not to CAC - official game thread

Crazy stuff here. I guess considering all of the fees paid on that coin it should get two beans.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'll go with yes on the green. Nice coin. Looks like it has great luster.

 

I will go with a green bean. Peace brother.

 

I think I see blotches and dings on each photo, but when I compare the two obverse pictures with each other - due to the lighting they each have different dings. So, I don't know what to think. Not being certain, I'll vote no.

On another note, I have used the Novus plastic cleaning and scratch remover products with success in getting rid of a lot of scratches on slabs.

 

Green Bean.

jom

 

Green ...it looks acceptable for a 65 (not PQ in my opinion, but at least "B" level).

 

Appears solid for '65.........green bean.

 

Solid for the grade or squarely in the middle, but no one above mentions the Ah factor! She's a beaut, colorwise, has character beyond her grade and that could eclipse "better examples", which is what set coins apart for little ol me. Lovely. Greenie.

 

Very nice looking. Yes to the green bean

 

Green bean

 

I'm thinking it got a green sticker.

 

Anyone?

 

Nice luster - yes to CAC green

 

Maybe JA needed to clean his glasses on that one. I wonder what the result would be if it was sent back in today? If it did bean then it would tell me that maybe these things aren't worth a hill of beans.

 

No bean on the $5 AU-58

 

Who's next? I'd like to get back in line for one also....

jom

 

I believe I'm up next. Here's an 1851 Half Cent that's graded by PCGS as AU58+. Does it get a bean or not?