pjd1966 aka Pamela J. Donnelly has been NARU'd by eBay

Silverfox et al-- Insofar as we know right now, estatedoctor is not Pamela Donnelly aka pjd1966. From what an investigation determined (I'd prefer not to give details at this time), Dr. Irvin Clark is who he says he is. He happens to live in pjd1966's general part of Savannah, GA without knowing her nor knowing who she is. He had the misfortune to buy a very large amount ($4K+) of Pamela's junk at a yard sale she was having, apparently her desperate gasp to sell her crap by any means possible. He listed the items as estatedoctor and was immediately inudated with emails of protest and accusation. Meantime, so many reports went into eBay stating that estatedoctor was pjd1966 in disguise that eBay suspended him. Clearly, he has been reinstated. I'm personally not particularly happy with his generic non-descriptive description, but he is apparently legitimate.

This situation is still evolving, but as it stands now, there is no known association between pjd1966 and estatedoctor other than he dropped a bundle at her yard sale.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

If this is the truth then why have people emailed me and stated that she has sent them garbage and they had to get their money back through paypal? This person if legitimate is just as bad as Pamela for sure not stating that these are fake, counterfeit, and replica items. Sorry but I do not buy his story and even if it is true he is just another ripoff artist and should be stopped. Sells a guy a fake Marilyn Monroe USO card for 200 bucks give me a break. You can buy these cards stated as copies on eBay for five bucks.
Legitimate o no this person is just another snake waiting to strike at the unwary. If its not Pamela then why the private auctions? Why buying bubblewrap from the same outfit that she bought from? Why the same items she buys online that are fakes and sells for outrageous prices? Why not stating that these are copies, reproductions, etc?
Give me a break I am 68 years old and no one is going to fool this old-time coin collector and antique collector. This is a doctor who has to sell online to make a living?
Anyway, I reported him and pointed out his misrepresentations so if they boot him more power to the people!

 

"Hi everyone! Please bear with me on the pictures and discription.I am very new to all this. I am doing the best i can. I have so much to sell.I have been assigned to sell and large amount of really cool items.Please keep checking my sight.I want you all to know that if you are not happy with the item for any reason return the item for a full refund.100 percent guarantee! These items appear to be in really good condition.Buying this items pictured."

NOW THIS SOUNDS LIKE A DOCTOR TO YOU ON THIS DESCRIPTION. THIS GUY SPENT 8 YEARS IN COLLEGE AND SPELLS LIKE THIS?

 

I did not state that his items were not junk; I merely stated that estatedoctor is not pjd1966, but that he is selling her junk, purportedly purchased from her at a yard sale according to sources. What we do NOT know at this time is whether or not he is selling FOR Pamela on her behalf. What we DO know is that he is not selling coins and thus his auctions cease to be our concern and become irrelevant for our purposes. While I do not condone his nor any other less-than-open-and-honest eBay auctions, I am not in a position nor am I willing to take any action against him.

Because he is not attempting to sell any coins, it is beyond the purview of numismatic influence and this forum to pursue him. If the buyers of his fake or reproduction Babe Ruth and Elvis posters or cheap costume jewelry masquerading as antiques wish to pursue him for fraud, then they must become organized in a likewise manner as we numismatists did with pjd1966. He is already starting to receive less-than-sterling feedback, so a foundation is being poured for eventual suspension.

BTW, it is not at all clear that he is an MD; he may only have his doctorate in physical education which may account for his poor grammar - or his "Doctor" title may be honorary or self-granted.

 

Thanks for the information! But, did everyone feel this way before when she was not selling coins? Believe me she is behind all of this using a shill to run her auctions. I never saw anyone write a description like Pamela does and this is sure as shootin her words. Plus, give him or her time they will start selling coins and then it will become everyones' concern. I sincerely doubt that this person is anything short of devious and sells just exactly like good ole pjd1966. I think this forum should also be dedicated to honesty and the good ole American sense of justice for all regardless of what it involves.

 

Okay folks. The subject has been thoroughly covered from every angle even remotely related to numismatics, so let's move on.