Looks like the ones I used to use a Brillo pad on as all the scratches also go over the rim, in multiple directions.
Looks like a that coin cleaning acid garbage on ebay. You know, the stuff that completely etches the surface, AND you have to use steel wool or a steel wire brush in order for it to work effectively? God, I HATE that stuff.
I think this is it. Rides on the success of nic-a-date https://www.ebay.com/itm/Nic-A-Spra...356973?hash=item4b5e393e2d:g:vloAAOSwy2NcbtpD
Here it is. Basically PMD in a bottle. https://www.ebay.com/itm/Nic-A-Pak-...396444?hash=item4b5e39d85c:g:m4gAAOSwZcZcbtnr
The stuff that once you read the directions that tell you in the fine print, to wear a respirator and wear rubber gloves and you have done neither..........
Don't worry, I've used nic-a-date a thousand time, and haven't ended up in the hospital yet! Still waiting for that fateful day when I need a CAT scan for one thing, then it turns I have brain cancer though... (BTW, I do use gloves, but not a respirator).