It's East Henrietta Road - Gallery of Coins is the correct name. He is usually closed by 1 or 2 PM. McLeod Stamp and Coin in Brighton (not Pittsford) closed in March, and the business and all inventory was sold to downstate dealers. That same location has reopened as Brighton Coin and Token (no stamps) under new ownership. I don't know of any reasonably stocked coin dealers who have the majority of their stock in the glass cases... wouldn't be much to pick from in most stores.
That's amazing, never thought they would close it up. I haven't been there in at least 2 years. I was always amazed at the selection that Gallery of Coins had. I had always assumed McLeod's was in Pittsford, I never paid attention to where the border of the two towns is. I will definitely have to make my way down to brighton coin