Should I submit these Morgan dollars for grading?

Hello all,

Should I submit these Morgan dollars for grading or isnt worth the time?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

NO I would not suggest it
The first has damage and the second is not naturally toned IMO

 

Not convinced that 1889S is genuine.

 

i bought it from a reputable coin dealer, it has the correct weight too. Is it the tone?

 

Maybe just the pic, but the date and some of the lettering looks off to me. The D in Dollar looks too narrow, etc.

Let's get some more opinions.

 

No. The first is damaged and the second one just seems...off.

 

How much would these coins be worth with the grades you expect ? Conversely, how much did you pay for them ?

 

The 89-S looks bad. The digits in the date are too narrow, and the details in the hair and feathers are too sharp for the wear apparent on the coin.

 

89 S is a bad fake. Silly looking!

 

It would be a waste of money to do so. Damaged, Artificially Toned and that 1893-S is a fake. Just look at it compared to the others.

 

Um, if you're seeing an 1893-S, I think you need to look more closely...

 

It's a fake 1893-S.

 

A really bad fake, then; they got the date wrong!

 

My mistake Jeff. I said 1893-S but I meant 1889-S. Maybe I need a nap.

 

Reputable? Did he/she mention any of the obvious problems? I’d call the 1892 “Scarface” and the 1889-S “Mrs Bad Penny”.

 

If you just want to try and have them graded if you have 8 more coins to go with them you can send them to ANACS when they have there 10 coins for $10 each Special

 

Neiter are worth grading. As stated above, the 1889 S is a counterfeit

 

To the cornfield with that dealer!

 

Are you serious. Of course no