Grading a 1907 $20 Liberty

Crossing this over to PCGS. What do you think it will grade? I will disclose current grade after some responses come in.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Wow! Check out that luster!! A lot of chatter. I don't know, I hate going first. MS something..65? 66?

 

Agree about the chatter. This is a sparkler. MS-64. Reverse is nicer.
Without all the chatter it's very high MS.

 

MS64

 

Stunning coin..... But due to bag marks I say MS-63.

 

Oh lord that is sweet! Gonna sell that one for melt?

63 Obverse
66 Reverse

 

LOL Randy!! I am keeping this one. The two other ladies that came with her I sold for melt today!!

 

64. Or if it was on eBay 64 almost *+ L@@k R@RE

 

Well let me know when storage becomes an issue!

 

64

 

These alloyed 90% golds are a little softer than their alloyed silver counterparts. I'm giving the girl a break, MS64.

 

62.

 

MS64, if they don't notice the tiny dings on the shield, 65

 

Great job everyone!! I dont think it will hit 65 but might be worth a try with my next submittal.

 

Congrats, @ilmcoins. She's a beauty.

 

They did not take anything off for the ding on the date on this one MS65 on PCGS website...

 

Blows on fingernails, buffs on lapels.

 

Hmm, this would seem to be an instance of grade inflation to me. I have a 1907-S graded MS-60 (albeit in an old green PCGS holder) that's equally as nice, if not nicer.

 

+1 average out at 64

 

This 1907-D $20 Liberty is graded MS-64. There is another picture of the OP coin on the PCGS blog that makes this piece look like an MS-63 from another angle. I think that the PCGS grade will be MS-63.