Submit for reconsideration: YES or NO ?

I have a few coins I believe should either have higher grades, or copper coins that are RB and not BN. I would love to get any feedback on experiences you may have had doing this with PCGS and NGC.

Many thanks,
Mr. I

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

We'll need large, sharp pictures of the coins AND labels to make reasonable recommendations.

 

I guess I was wondering how successful reconsiderations were. I mean they can just look at it real fast and say nope, nope, nope. And if I submit say 7 coins are they going to say "yeah we got all these wrong have to give these and upgrade" If it's a reasonable thing to do than great, I just never have done it before.

 

So I just recently purchased this Lincoln, I think it should be higher than 67+...your feelings?

 

I also have this Lincoln, this is the best looking cent of my entire collection, really incredible looking. If it upgraded a half it would come PCGS highest graded example.

 

Thank you

 

I'd save my money.

 

Why would you spend money on regrading? Two nice coins with CAC stickers. Hard to do much better than that.

 

Maybe if CAC had given them a gold bean, but yours have a green bean.
Both PCGS and CAC believe they have been given the proper grade.
Do what you will with them, but don't send them for reconsideration.

 

I guess I was hoping to get "THE" highest graded example...

Thank you so much for taking time to look and respond, really cool!!

 

Thank you, I didn't know about gold beans, something to look for in the future. Thank you for your time, very cool.

 

Thank you

 

Since there are two opinions (PCGS and CAC) on those coins that agree, trying for something better is, like others have said, a waste of money.

 

When you get grades like this on these types of coins, be happy with what you have. It’s way more than most people can expect or receive. In other words, don’t poke a sleeping bear in the ribs.

 

Please elaborate

 

Last year I submitted a PCGS MS66+ WLH dollar (which had a green CAC sticker) to NGC for a crossover. It crossed at MS67, so they must have liked he coin as much as I did

But I agree with Rick, the 51-S Lincoln you posted is maxed-out. And I don’t think “RB” copper coins will be upgraded to “RD”. On the contrary, the TPGs guarantee doesn’t include color designations as far as I remember.

 

Leave as is. Me be happy with it.