@ddoomm1 wins! I paid $564 for it. @Lehigh96 was second at $525. Thanks for guessing. The floor is open.
I have another from the Aurora Orban Collection. 1881 S MS64* PCGS Price Guide has it listed at $75. 1881 S MS64 star by JPeace$ posted Jan 16, 2018 at 9:41 PM 1881 S MS64 star reverse by JPeace$ posted Jan 16, 2018 at 9:41 PM
I have no idea. I haven't checked in a while. I still own it and I can guarantee you it's still in the holder I posted. Thanks for letting me know though. I'll be calling NGC to inquire about it.
I'll end it here so @ddddd can update the scores. My bad for not letting you do that yesterday before posting again. @Pickin and Grinin wins this round. I paid $1080 for the coin. I went back to page 1 to read the rules. It didn't say you couldn't go over, so that makes Pickin and Grinin the winner. I know it's a huge premium for the coin, but you don't see many like it and I bid what I needed to at the auction to win it.