This is a bit more complicated than just valuing the quarters. My set includes the varieties by Browning number. I don't know any catalog (book or website) that goes into that much depth. Rarity 1, 2 and maybe 3 I can probably treat the same. But 9 of my 34 coins are in the Rarity 4 to 5+ range. They merit a higher value. (I am only missing the two rarest varieties, an R-6+ and an R-8.) A large percentage of the coins sold are not labeled with the Browning number. I can probably get a few prices realized from Heritage and Stack's. Bottom Line: Is there a price listing that covers all the Browning numbers?
Honestly, I don't know that there is anything like that. I would suggest compiling a list of prices realized, without the buyers premium, through the various acutions sites for the last 2-3 years of each of your coins. That will at least provide a clearer picture of what is in demand and how it is trading.
Buyers premium should be included, the buyer had to pay it. You could even include a few more bucks for shipping which the buyer also had to pay when trying to value something.
Steve Tompkins, the author of the Early United States Quarters book, sells an Auction Appearances and Prices Realized guide. He claims that it has listings for all grades and all die marriages. I do not own this guide, but it appears to be the best option for a bust quarter die marriage price guide. http://www.earlyunitedstatescoins.c...es_Quarters_1796_-_1838_-_Newest_Edition.html
Ooooooo, nice. Since I'm still looking for the two I'm missing AND the one DETAILS coin plus upgrades to some of my others, I'm going to jump all over this opportunity. Thanks, bunches.
