ANOTHER overgraded PCGS Morgan

I’m not thrashing Cointalk, but facts are facts, CU has more experienced & knowledgeable members. Perhaps rather than hinting that I should be banned you should step back and realize that you have been trolling Baseball21 for months. You know, glasses houses and such.

I want the name of the people you are referring to on the CU forum. Why are you so afraid? Have you already been banned once over there? Are you using an alt?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I can comment on whatever I want, I don’t need your permission. And if you read my responses regarding the “racism” card, I was equally harsh on Baseball21 as well.

We aren’t tied to the hip, other than we are the prime targets of your incessant trolling!

 

More silly inferences on your part.

I never hinted for anyone to be banned. What I hinted at is for someone to stop being a hypocrite. Don’t call the grass greener on the other side but then run back to the outcasts.

I have not been banned on any forums nor have I ever had an alt on a forum.

 

Not yet!

 

Again being a hypocrite. First you are incensed that I would even hint at you beeing banned (when I said that I don’t want you banned) but you announce with glee that I should be banned. I thought higher of you.

 

Incensed, lol. Now who is making silly inferences.

When you said that you don’t want me banned, I didn’t believe you. If you want me to believe things like that, stop trolling me.

How can you think higher of someone who you are actively trolling with every post?

 

I thought higher of you from prior posts. I’m not trolling; I’m countering your consistent propaganda.

 

Omg, I don’t know what is more laughable, that you claim to not be trolling or you claim that I’m spreading propaganda.

Ready to give the name yet?

 

"What is this, propaganda?"
-Mae West, My Little Chickadee (1940)

 

The only thing laughable is that you fail to recognize your follies.

If you recall, you were the first to mention "grading errors" on one of my threads (the Star Walker):

https://www.cointalk.com/threads/guess-the-grade-1941-s-walking-liberty-half.324983/page-4

And you even went so far as to say:

"And my collection is heavily invested in the star designation so coins like this one hurt the credibility of the star and devalue other coins with a star, so when I see a coin with a star that doesn’t deserve it, it will not keep quiet."


Then I posted a toned Morgan that by all looks was just as much of a "grading error" and could hurt the credibility of many properly graded coins. But no! Here you stepped in and started arguing that the grade was fine, that we can't judge from a picture (but we can with the Star Walker?), etc...

Since then it's just been a large back and forth. Just like you originally stated, I couldn't keep quiet. There is room for leeway in grading (it's something that will always have some subjective nature to it). However, there have been enough egregious examples where the credibility of the TPGs begins to loosen. If the TPGs (and the people that continue to defend them) can realize that and make just a few changes, then we all would be in a much better place and have less need for such debates (yes there will always be some mechanical errors, but even those numbers can be significantly decreased and handled with better customer service responses).

 

So you admit to trolling me since that point. Nice!

 

Wow this thread has really gone off of the rails...

 

I don't understand all this "troll" name calling. All it sounds like to me is a couple guys fussing back and forth with neither side stopping.

 

Here's a troll:

 

It really is a shame that you learned nothing from that post and revert back to silly name calling. Continue with your spiel if you so choose.

@C-B-D you can rest assured as I'm done with this thread now.

 

I agree with ending THIS argument.
I produced a PCGS Morgan Dollar that shouldnt even sniff a superb gem grade.
I would say most members agreed with that notion. That coin is waaaaaaay too baggy for the grade....The luster, and teeny bit of reverse rainbow dont bump it up THAT far
@ddddd and i BOTH collect toned Morgan Dollars. We know what we are talking about.
It was a grading mistake- End of discussion.

 

The tread stocking that has been displayed has been creepy at best.

It is what it is though. Some people troll and bash people over the head to feel like they're an expert