Clean cheek can't see any nicks for that matter. True views are hard to determine luster but I'm gonna say it's very bright. Might be high but I'm gonna say MS66
AU 58 ...I agree this is one of those that could be on the MS 63-64/AU 58 border, but I'll say it's slight wear on the high points and thus it's AU.
Where are you guys seeing wear? I don't see any wear anywhere. I see some toning breaks on the eagle's feathers, but I don't see anything that looks like wear. I do see a weak strike, and I see quite a bit of disturbance on the cheek. I also don't see much luster, but I see fantastic toning. I'd call this one a 64.