1938 D nickel ms65 CAC Gold

would the cac gold sticker justify paying double the grey sheet price? cant provide pic at work, but I was just checking out a auction site and was like wow really double the price.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

buffalo by the way

 

Not in my opinion.

 

I friggin had to talk a call, it ended now I cant find it to see if it sold dam lol

 

found it, went $80 plus buyers fee $90.00
that's just crazy IMO

 

Not for me either.

 

you know either I am missing something or great collections is a great place to sell coins. I have my handy dandee june issue of the grey sheet, and im going thru the auction looking for deals and I am noticing, coins are selling double and triple retail price. I know you want there to be a move up in price, not down, but dam a $20 coin going for $60 to $70 dollars plus buyers fees, I just don't get it. Or the greysheet is terrible at pricing, idk.

 

$120 plus fees = $135.00 IDK Im not seeing $135.00

 

in all honesty sounds like you’re missing a ton. You’re missing CAC premiums, you’re missing toning premiums, you’re missing quality ect. The best coins don’t sell for greysheet. You’re hyper focused on the grade and ignoring the rest it sounds like. Price guide buyers get average coins at best.

135 sounds about right if not low for a Morgan with those colors

Also yes a gold CAC can EASILY justify double or more for price