This one looked good with the scans. Should be here next week. What do you think? It's impossible to see any luster on the coin, but there's a lot of meat on the bone.
I think the same thing you do. I've seen a lot of coins with a surface that looks like that in-hand -- ugly gray and dusty. But if it looks like that from a flatbed scan, I think there's a very good chance that there is plenty of luster left. Good find -- can't wait to see photos!
Nice one. I think there is a very strong possibility that it will grade AU-58. The pictures were taken with a scanner, which tends to make coins look worse than they actually are.