Mystery 1955 penny?

Is that the Paul I met in CT? Because that Paul certainly did and I have a witness so stop with the whole trying to discredit what I say and call me a lier because it's really rude and ignorant. OK? That's fact. I don't know why people are so jealous, this is supposed to be constructive to find some truth. Don't call me a lier I take offense to that.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'm not the first, nor will I be the last, to say that if you believe it's
a genuine error, please submit it to any authentication service
you wish - ANACS, PCGS, or NGC.

The only way to show we are wrong, including me, is to have it certified as an error.

If you choose not to submit it for authentication, then we will have to assume that you
know it's not genuine, but can't accept that as fact, so you'll continue to tell us what you'd
like to believe about the coin. If your believe is so strong, please show us you're correct.

If not, what you say about your coin is the same as saying "I have an 1849 $20 gold piece,
but since no one will believe me, I won't send it out for authentication".

 

Stop what? You don't have to be here, nobody is forcing you. You're interested for a reason, just like me dude. Don't tell me to stop researching what this is just because you don't want to.

 

How about this:

'YOU'RE A LIAR'

Paul D.F. from ANACS never said that your cent is worth
$20,000, or that he would pay $20,000 for it.

If I'm rude and ignorant for saying that, just prove me wrong.

Please have Paul call me and tell me he said that to you about your
coin. You won't, because you can't.

Do I need to be any clearer ?

 

no he didn't.

 

Bravo!

 

I'm closing my office for the day, so I won't
get any more entertainment till tomorrow morning.

In the meantime.....enjoy yourselves!

By the way, I've been lied to by better lier's, and told I don't
know what I'm talking about, by people a heck of a lot more
intelligent than the person I helped in 2015, and earlier this morning,
so him telling me I'm ignorant doesn't mean anything to me.

The only thing I'm guilty of is trying to have a battle of wits
with an unarmed opponent. (or a one-armed opponent, if I want to be nice)

See ya all tomorrow morning

 

That was a rockin’ tune.... Just sayin’...

 

I can pull a rock from my driveway and one could spend many lifetimes trying to find a perfect match without ever doing so. Does this mean there's a market for said stones or that they're in any way special?

I've no doubt your coin is unique, but this doesn't make it at all special or valuable. All the claimed "facts" and run-on nonsense simply will not change this.

Still, exactly what do you expect from the board? You clearly cannot handle the fact we disagree, so what's the acceptable alternative?

 

Really? Who's jealous? Must be all of us I guess. Give it back, it's mine. It's my precioussss.

 

Indeed... I was always quite fond of it and "She's a Beauty". As good as they are, Vince's late stint with the Dead made him immortal.

 

So anyway, are you planning on getting it graded or not? Clearly if it really is what you are claiming you know it will have to be graded. So are you?

Cheers,

 

Wow. I was the first to answer this question and then didn't get any notifications. Come back to 4 pages of solid gold Thanks guys!

 

Paul De Felice and Paul Joseph are two different people. Paul Joseph does the Norwich, Connecticut show not Paul De Felice.

 

This coin is fine art, a historical piece, I can accept that. If it's a genuine error, then cool. Like I told you I'm interested in the history, what happened and if this coin has something to do with the whole 55 error process at the mint. I don't really care to grade it because it's a lucky coin and I don't wanna send it in the mail. I'm not trying to sell it. I don't want it out of my possession it's a priceless good luck charm. There's no way to not mail it either, I talked to PCGS when I met you at the Expo in LA. I'd take it if I could but I can't. I tried to grade it in a way I felt comfortable doing but it's against their rules. Call me superstitious that's ok. You've seen 1000's of coins Fred, you have a picture of anything like this? Any story from 55, anything? PCGS sent me to you at the Expo too, just saying. Is it possible you're being hasty in your evaluation? It's not about a competition, it's just a truth. Are we correct to assume it's damaged and are we missing out on a story by doing that? The ST is odd. It takes that moment to really think about it. Without the ST, it's just a hammer slam that somehow got dome shaped...With the ST, it's a complete mystery. I'm simply trying to solve this mystery. You are one the best sources for this in the world, if anyone has seen something similar to this, then it's you. You haven't convinced me it's damaged though, you haven't given any examples as to why. You quickly looked at it and because you've seen hammered coins before, made a snap judgment that it's damaged and that's all there is to it. When maybe there's possibilities you're not taking the time to think of? That maybe this coin was dancing around in some strange way inside the machine like Paul was saying. Possible? If you say no, and Paul says yes, and you're talking about the same machine, then is it physically possible or simply something you don't want to or can't accept yourself? I basically have two people telling me a different story of whats even possible to happen. You would know I think, has a coin ever flipped around in the tube before?

 

I think you should show it to Paul Joseph again.
He should be at the Auburn, MA show on June 10th.
It is at the Auburn Elks on Rt. 12.

 

I got a witness dude, need to hear that again? I have a witness to Paul from Anacs saying he'd pay me $20,000 for this coin. In Norwich CT dude...so yeah, I'm not responding to people who call me a liar after this. That's really petty and immature.

 

Cool thank you, will you be there too? I'll bring it if I'm around and you can see it for yourself. That's why I'm here going public, because I'm asking for help. Not to argue with people who have no open mind.

 

With all due respect, just go do what you need to do. Why are you trying to prove your case here by saying it over and over again? It's going to make people here think you are lier-ing.