I'm following the guidance from the Redbook on Indian Head Cents by Rick Snow. Focusing on primarily coins less than $150 except key dates and mint marks. So, mostly AU50 and up for the common dates and dropping down to XF or lower depending upon the date and mint mark for key dates. Can't wait for the next local coin show.
I highly recommen this site Indianheadvarities.com that way some of your finds may have more bang for the buck.