21 D Walker

Opinions please...

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Cleaned.
Lots of 9-3 hairlines.

 

Ditto

 

I Have one also didnt see many till I got one then saw many more. Opinions please

 

Thanks for reply. Like the hat

 

Nice and original VG.

 

I felt that it was cleaned also...this (IMO) is an example of subjective grading...and maybe a goof on PCGS's part.
Sold for 242.50 this am.

 

Album slide marks, this shouldn’t have been straight graded. That said, the 21-D is a pretty tough coin, so I don’t completely disagree with the price realized.

 

PCGS price guide of 290...recent sales from 167 to 223. Thanks for everyone's input.

 

need one to complete my set. nice one above!

 

Looks like a VG10 to me. Maybe they called it G6 b/c of the light hairlines?

 

I agree with Mike.

 

Mike, the light hairlines (IMO) are cleaning marks...either way, I would not buy the coin and I think PCGS goofed on this one.

 

Here's my 21-D G4

 

Hairlines aside, I was between G-4 and VG so 06 seems correct. 5th in my class at the Ed Wood School of Grading. Fantastic key date. The squeaky key dates get the grading grease.

 

I've looked it over, as well as possible. I say VG 10. IMO PCGS grades key dates quite harshly. I've seen plenty, undergraded a grade or so.

I've always kinda stayed away from the walkers because of the 1921 dates and other keys.

 

still a decent looking coin despite the wipe.

 

Looks good to me!! I lack only this mint/date in my set.